Cinema News

October 27, 2025 | View in browser

By George Skelton

Capitol Journal Columnist

Gov. Gavin Newsom's anti-Trump, anti-Texas congressional redistricting gamble seems about to pay off.

Newsom's bet on Proposition 50 is looking like a winner, although we won't really know until the vote count is released starting election night Nov. 4.

Insiders closely watching the high-stakes campaign would be shocked if Republicans pulled an upset and defeated the Democrats' retaliatory response to red state gerrymandering.

They talk mostly about the expected size of victory, not whether it will win. The hedged consensus is that it'll be by a modest margin, not a blowout.

Any size victory would help Newsom promote himself nationally as the Democrat whom party activists anxiously seek to aggressively fight Trumpism. It could energize grassroots progressives to back the Californian in early 2028 presidential primaries.

Propositions 50's defeat, however, could be a devastating blow to Newsom's presidential aspirations. If Californians wouldn't follow him, why should other people?

Private and independent polls have shown Proposition 50 being supported by a small majority of registered voters. Not enough for an early victory dance. But the opposition is nowhere close to a majority. A lot of people have been undecided. They may not even bother to vote in a special election with only one state measure on the ballot.

As of last week, the return of mail-in ballots was running about the same as in last year's presidential election at the same point — very unusual.

A slightly higher percentage of Democrats were casting ballots than GOP registrants. This is particularly significant in a state where 45% of voters are Democrats and only 25% are Republicans. The GOP needs a humungous turnout to beat Democrats on almost anything.

You can credit President Trump's antics for riling up Democrats to vote early.

One practical importance of early Democratic voting is that the "yes" side doesn't need to spend more money appealing to people who have already mailed in their ballots.

"It's a bird in the hand kind of thing," says Paul Mitchell, the Democrats' chief data processor and principal drawer of the gerrymandered congressional maps up for approval in Proposition 50.

Mitchell believes the large recent weekend turnouts in California of "No Kings" protesters are indicative of the anti-Trump outrage that is generating Democratic enthusiasm for Proposition 50.

Republican consultant Rob Stutzman thinks that Proposition 50 could have been beaten with enough money. But not nearly enough showed up. Potential donors probably concluded it was a lost cause, he says. Don't waste the cash.

It takes ridiculous amounts of money to win a competitive statewide race in California, with 23 million diverse voters scattered over hundreds of miles and several costly media markets.

Keep up with California

Your support helps us deliver the news that matters most. Subscribe to the Los Angeles Times.

Subscribe Now

Democrats, with their unmatched California power, have raised well over $100 million from unions, billionaire Democratic donors and other political investors.

Billionaire hedge-fund founder Tom Steyer put up $12 million. There are rumors he's tempted to run for governor.

Los Angeles developer Rick Caruso is thinking very seriously about entering the 2026 gubernatorial race. He just paid for 100,000 pro-50 mail pieces in L.A. County, aimed at those least likely to vote.

One problem for the opposition is that it never unified behind a main anti-50 message. It ranged from "reject Newsom's power grab" to "win one for Trump" and a purist lecture about retaining California's current congressional districts drawn by a voter-created good government citizens' commission.

The basic pro-50 message is simply, as Steyer says in his TV ad: "Stick it to Trump."

This contest at its core is about which party controls Congress after next year's midterm elections — or whether Republicans and Democrats at least share power. It's about whether there'll be a Congress with some gumption to confront a power-mad, egotistical president.

The fight started when Trump banged on Texas to redraw — gerrymander — its congressional districts to potentially gain five more Republican seats in the House of Representatives. Democrats need only a slight pickup to capture House control — and in an off-year election, the non-presidential party tends to acquire many.

Texas obediently obliged the nervous Trump, and other red states also have.

Newsom responded by urging the California Legislature to redraw this state's maps to potentially gain five Democratic seats, neutralizing Texas' underhanded move. The lawmakers quickly did. But in California, voter approval is needed to temporarily shelve the independent commission's work. That's what Proposition 50 does.

It also would boost Newsom's standing among party activists across America.

"He's been trying to claim the national leadership on anti-Trump. This is a chance for him to show he can deliver," says UC Berkeley political scientist Eric Schickler. "There's a sense the party doesn't know how to fight back.

"On the flip side, if he were unable to persuade California voters to go along with him, it would be a hard sell to show Democrats nationally he's the best person to take on Republicans."

"It's a gamble," says UC San Diego political science professor Thad Kousser. "If 50 wins, he's a person who can effectively fight back against Donald Trump. If it loses, he has no hope of winning on the national level."

But veteran political consultant Mike Murphy — a former Republican who switched to independent — thinks Newsom could survive voters' rejection of Proposition 50.

"It would take some of the shine off him. But he'd still be a contender. It wouldn't knock him out. The worst you could say was that he lost 50 but was fighting the good fight.

"If 50 wins, Gavin might have a good future as a riverboat gambler if he puts all the chips in."