| The Super Bowl is over. Going to Disneyland? Do you have a spare $1,000 to spend? |
| I'm Glenn Whipp, columnist for the Los Angeles Times, host of The Envelope newsletter and the guy wondering about the profit margin on a $6 churro. |
| In the meantime, welcome back to the newsletter as we push through to the Oscars on March 15. Have you been catching up on the nominated movies? "Sentimental Value" is a delight ... though just how delightful has been the subject of some debate. |
Are the Actor Awards global enough? |
| Joachim Trier's richly rewarding family drama "Sentimental Value" hauled in nine Oscar nominations last month, setting a record for most acting nods for a non-English-language movie. |
| Its primary quartet of actors — Stellan Skarsgård as a legendary director angling for a comeback, Renate Reinsve and Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas as his daughters and Elle Fanning as an A-list actor who becomes entangled in the family drama — all received nods. Fanning's name was the first called when nominations were announced, signaling that Scandinavian melancholy would be notably absent that morning. Never mind the hour: Champagne glasses were raised. |
| |
| The celebratory scene stood in stark contrast to the vibe just two weeks earlier when "Sentimental Value" was blanked at the Actor Awards (formerly known as the Screen Actors Guild Awards). And it wasn't the only international film ignored. The 2,500 SAG-AFTRA nomination committee voters also shunned Wagner Moura, the lead of celebrated Brazilian drama "The Secret Agent." Moura went on to nab an Oscar nomination, one of four noms, including best picture, that Kleber Mendonça Filho's drama earned. |
| The disparity between the choices of the motion picture academy and SAG-AFTRA could be an anomaly. Or it might be the latest evidence of an Oscar trend this decade. As the academy's membership has become more global — 24% of Oscar voters live outside the United States — the Academy Awards have become increasingly an international affair, leading to a widening divide with the Hollywood guilds. |
| Is this a bad thing? It depends who you ask. If you queried the actors that SAG-AFTRA nominated who ended up being Oscar also-rans, the answer would be no. Those who believe that cinema is global, particularly now that American studios have largely abandoned making movies geared toward grown-ups, would have a different response. |
| "The fact that not one international film got in says a lot," says a veteran awards consultant, who, like others interviewed, requested anonymity in order to speak freely about the industry. Indeed, one journalist tabbed SAG's Actor Awards nominations the "'America First' List," which, while technically accurate, might have taken the perceived xenophobia a bit far. |
| "The SAG Awards or Actor Awards — whatever they're called now — are in danger of looking like a middlebrow affair," another awards campaigner notes. "I know this is going to sound elitist, but it's true. There's a big difference between an organization where you have to be invited or apply to join versus one where, if you're a disc jockey in Kansas City, you have voting rights." |
| |
| To be fair, DJs, Kansas City-based or otherwise, probably don't vote for the Actor Awards' nominations — just for the final awards. In the nominations round, 2,500 randomly selected active SAG-AFTRA members make the choices. To serve on the committee, members must be categorized as an actor/performer, dancer, singer or stuntperson in the SAG-AFTRA database. Could a DJ be classified as a performer? Probably not. In the guild's view, actor and performer are synonymous, encompassing both principal and background players. |
| And sure, since only 7% of SAG-AFTRA actors and performers earn $80,000 or more a year, that means there are going to be a few full-time waiters on those nomination committees. But as the speeches at the Actor Awards remind us annually, it's a profession where you're just one job away from making it. Think of Connor Storrie, who worked at restaurants for eight years before getting his break on "Heated Rivalry." |
| There's still the question of why, say, SAG-AFTRA dancers and singers are voting on the merits of an acting performance, however. In contrast to the Actor Awards, nominations for the Oscars are decided by the academy's various branches. Actors vote for actors, writers for screenplays and so on, with the general membership voting for best picture. |
| "Peer groups are deciding what's worthy, and that's the way it should be," says an academy member from the public relations branch. "I'm not voting for visual effects." |
| Not initially, at least. Academy members vote for all 24 categories in the final round, provided, per a rule change that went into effect this year, they attest to watching all the nominated work in the category. |
| Keep up with California | Your support helps us deliver the news that matters most. Subscribe to the Los Angeles Times. | | | | | |
| SAG-AFTRA voters have rewarded non-English-language work over the years, but usually when a particular film or TV show — Bong Joon Ho's 2019 masterpiece "Parasite" or Netflix's "Squid Game" — is undeniable. Voters ignored recent lead turns from Fernanda Torres ("I'm Still Here"), Yalitza Aparicio ("Roma") and Sandra Hüller ("Anatomy of a Fall"). All three went on to earn lead actress Oscar nominations. |
| This year's snubbing of "Sentimental Value" is particularly puzzling as the movie featured well-known actors like Fanning and Skarsgård, an institution from roles in blockbuster franchises like "Pirates of the Caribbean" and most recently the TV series "Andor." It's also a film about, among other things, the blurring of art and reality and the challenges of acting. And, in the scenes featuring Fanning, it's in English. |
| What gives? Like every other contender, "Sentimental Value" screened four times for voters and was available for streaming. |
| "I just think people are less inclined to watch a movie with subtitles at home," says one awards consultant, alluding to the ways that passive, multiscreen viewing has encroached upon our multitasking lives. Maybe that's why Skarsgård, when he accepted the Golden Globe award for his work in the movie, preached that "cinema should be seen in cinemas" in his speech. |
| Does that sound elitist? It shouldn't. But it does seem to be a belief from a time that's slipping away. One certainty: With the academy nominating two international features for best picture for the third straight year, global cinema is now entrenched at the Oscars. Whether SAG-AFTRA voters decide to join the party is now a question for next year. |
